The New York Times reported
last week that Donald J. Trump had a $916 million net
operating loss on his 1995 tax returns, which could have legally allowed
him to avoid federal
income taxes for nearly two decades. That figure may seem startling, but
wealthy real estate
developers like Mr. Trump enjoy federal income tax breaks largely unavailable
to typical homeowners.
ADVANTAGE 1: BORROWING
TOBUY
When Mr. Trump purchases an
expensive piece of real estate — say, a New Jersey casino, a Las Vegas hotel or
a historic skyscraper in the financial district of Manhattan — he often
uses little of his own money, and the interest he pays on the loans is tax
deductible.
Through the mid-1990s, Mr. Trump often borrowed
heavily from banks and other investors. In the case of the Trump Taj Mahal
casino in Atlantic City, his company issued $675 million in high-interest
junk bonds to acquire the property and finish construction.
ADVANTAGE 2: LEGAL
OWNERSHIP STRUCTURES
Real estate investors like Mr.
Trump generally control properties through limited partnerships or
similar ownership structures. This allows the profits and losses to be treated
as individual income, while shielding Mr. Trump from lawsuits and from personal
liability for the corporation’s debt.
It also means that business losses can be used to
offset other personal income from taxation. When his Atlantic City casinos
began to fail in the early 1990s, Mr. Trump could have deducted the full
value of his businesses’ losses against his income, even though most of
themoney invested in them had been
borrowed.
ADVANTAGE 3: DEDUCTING
WEAR AND TEAR
As soon as one of his
properties opens, Mr. Trump can deduct a set percentage of its value each
year in a process calleddepreciation.
In the case of a billion-dollar casino, that could be
more than$25 million per year in deductions, until the entire purchase value
has been recovered around 40 years later, according to Bradley T. Borden, a
professor at Brooklyn Law School whospecializes in real estate taxation.
Mr. Trump can also use cost segregation to
separate the value of the building’s components — such as the gilded bathroom
fixtures and marbled interiors — from the value of the building, and depreciate
them on an even more aggressive timetable.
Mr. Trump is allowed to take full advantage of these
deductions to offset any of his personal income because he qualifies as
a real estate professional, someone who spends at least 750 hours a year
and more than 50 percent of his time working in real estate.
Most homeowners are not allowed to deduct the
depreciationof their home.
ADVANTAGE 4: NET
OPERATING LOSSES
The real estate industry stands
apart in the sheer scale of the amount of borrowedmoney it can take to make a
deal, which increases the size of the potential losses for a developer like Mr.
Trump. Exceptionally big losses can be used to avoid taxation for years. If Mr.
Trump’s business losses, combined with his other deductions, exceed his income,
he produces what is known as a net operating loss.
This type of loss, the same as a $916 million loss
that Mr. Trump reported in 1995, is useful because it can be carried
forward for the next 20 years (before 1997, it was 15 years) and used to avoid
paying income tax on his future income — like the more than $200 million
he claimed to have earned by appearing on the NBC television show “The
Apprentice.”
ADVANTAGE 5: CHAPTER 11
BANKRUPTCY
Mr. Trump’s businesses
have filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcyseveral times. Unlike
a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, which would liquidate a business, a Chapter
11 bankruptcy places its debts on hold while the business negotiates a
restructuring plan with its lenders.
Mr. Trump characterized the choice to repeatedly file
for Chapter 11 bankruptcy as a smart business move, saying in aninterview with
Forbes, “Basically, I’ve used the laws of the country to my advantage.”
During negotiations, Mr. Trump has used the threat of
years in bankruptcy court to force his lenders to forgive some of his
debt, allow longer and more forgivingpayment terms, and provide him
with additional loans to keep the properties afloat.
Normally, debt forgiveness would be taxable
income. But there are several ways he might be able to reduce or eliminate
it.Some real estate owners can take advantage of a special provision to avoid
paying this tax by forgoing future depreciation deductions.
ADVANTAGE 6: TIME TO SELL
For most investments, selling
at a loss counts as a capital loss, which can only be used on your taxes to
offset capital gains and a small amount of income.
But through a provision in the tax
code, thesale of business real estate
is counted as an ordinary loss instead. So if Mr. Trump had sold a casino
at a large loss, 100 percent of the loss could be used to offset his income
taxes, or added to his net operating loss to carry forward to future years.
ADVANTAGE 7: FLIPPING
REAL ESTATE
Let’s say that Mr. Trump sells
at a gain. If he quickly reinvests the proceeds from thesale into a new piece of real
estate, it qualifies as a like-kind exchange. This would allow him to
delay paying taxes on the gain until he sells the new property. If that
sale is also a like-kind exchange, Mr. Trump could continue to defer the taxes.
This can go on as long as Mr.
Trump continues to do like-kind exchanges. If the proceeds continue to be
reinvested in real estate until Mr. Trump dies, all income taxes on the
accumulated gains between the depreciated value and thesale price will vanish.
THE BOTTOM LINE
All of these tax advantages
are legal optionsavailable to real estate
developers under the current federal tax code. The extent to which they helped
Mr. Trump build his fortune by contributing to the $916 million net
operating loss shown in his 1995 records might never be fully understood
unless he chooses to release his tax returns.
0 commentaires:
Post a Comment